Спасибо Фаррух! Очень интересно. По поводу предположительно древнего возраста J1 на СК - и правда непонятно. Мне недавно Рой Кинг на dna-forums ответил так:
Kartveli, on 18 January 2012 - 22:05 PM, said:
But aren't the J1 DYS388<15 haplotypes more diverse in the south?
royk: As I look at supplementary table 4 from Yunusbayev et al the Tc for the J1 DYS388<15 is higher among the Caucasus samples (11.9 kya) than say Turkey/Assyria/Iran/Near East (9.6 kya).
I think that that's the only information we have that suggests that Z1834 has a Caucasus origin. Whether it is from Armenia/Georgia/NE Caucasus, I don't think we know yet. It would make sense if J-P58 (J1c3) has an origin further south in Anatolia/Fertile Crescent and there is old vicariance between J1c and Z1834.
Т.е. речь не о J1 (Z1842)+J1 (M368), а именно о J1 DYS388<15. Возможно на СК намного большее разнообразие. Не только Z1842+, но и Z1834+ Z1842-, может даже Z1834-.