АвторТема: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China  (Прочитано 1504 раз)

0 Пользователей и 1 Гость просматривают эту тему.

Оффлайн lndy980112Автор темы

  • Сообщений: 37
  • Страна: cn
  • Рейтинг +17/-0
  • Y-ДНК: R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532*
  • мтДНК: M8a3a
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #15 : 26 Май 2018, 14:11:08 »
With millions and millions direct ancestors, it's difficult to keep them all in the borders of a single country...)) However, I agree, it's difficult to change habitual thinking.
By the way, regarding your YFull number ELT50012CH. I wonder which lab you were tested in? Was it a part of any research program or private testing?
In China, many people regard their ancestors as great men like emperors, generals, and ministers. Even if they have a Family-Tree but I think only the DNA test can prove this. But now, people's understanding of DNA testing is just beginning.

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #16 : 26 Май 2018, 20:03:48 »
I found Evgeny Kolchugin's advice very irrelevant. Terribly non-useful. Wrong.

What does he suggest?
To check paternal line relatives?    :-\
To what?
What will this add?
Which new information?

We know:

1. Your ethnic profile doesn't have any European traces. I.e. your European ancestral connection is deeper than 4-5 generations. No closer than the beginning of the 19th century.
2. Your subclade is mostly European. "Slavic".

So, I'll try to ask people who work for R1a haplogroup to see and analize your data.

Онлайн Evgeny Kolchugin

  • Сообщений: 255
  • Страна: ru
  • Рейтинг +38/-0
  • Y-ДНК: R1a-YP5814; R1a-YP1698; R1a-YP578
  • мтДНК: K1a1b; Т2
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #17 : 26 Май 2018, 22:00:53 »
Цитировать
Just answer my question (if you can). What is your point? What do you want to receive with paternal relatives testing?
Цитировать
1. Your ethnic profile doesn't have any European traces. I.e. your European ancestral connection is deeper than 4-5 generations. No closer than the beginning of the 19th century.
Simple question. Do you know what is his knowledge of his patrilineage? How many generations / centuries back?

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #18 : 26 Май 2018, 22:07:19 »
Simple question. Do you know what is his knowledge of his patrilineage? How many generations / centuries back?

What can this change?
Why do you think that we need another sample?
We already have enough.

We absolutely don't need something else.
Except FTDNA STR testing. But even now it's possible to receive some answers.

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #19 : 26 Май 2018, 22:08:58 »
By autosomal results, we know there is not any European connection within 4-5 generations.
So what?

Онлайн Evgeny Kolchugin

  • Сообщений: 255
  • Страна: ru
  • Рейтинг +38/-0
  • Y-ДНК: R1a-YP5814; R1a-YP1698; R1a-YP578
  • мтДНК: K1a1b; Т2
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #20 : 26 Май 2018, 22:22:51 »
Цитировать
Just answer my question (if you can). What is your point? What do you want to receive with paternal relatives testing?
In response to your question... If he can trace his patrilineage for relatively long time, e.g. several centuries (and you do not know if he can or not), and can find a distant (potential) paternal relative with a common ancestor e.g. 200-300-400 years ago, and test that guy, he will at least know minimal time of presence of his "Slavic" patrilineage on the territory of China. Not enough? At his place, I would be happy to get this info.
« Последнее редактирование: 27 Май 2018, 07:53:56 от пенелопа »

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #21 : 26 Май 2018, 23:34:26 »
Eugene, what question are you talking about?

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #22 : 26 Май 2018, 23:43:20 »
We even don't try to find how. We're just looking fot time range.

Онлайн Evgeny Kolchugin

  • Сообщений: 255
  • Страна: ru
  • Рейтинг +38/-0
  • Y-ДНК: R1a-YP5814; R1a-YP1698; R1a-YP578
  • мтДНК: K1a1b; Т2
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #23 : 26 Май 2018, 23:43:59 »
Цитировать
Do you know your own Great(5)-granfather name?
Yes, I know. Also 5, 6, 7 and more...
Цитировать
One more time. Just listen and try to understand.
:-X

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #24 : 26 Май 2018, 23:44:27 »
The simplest way is to order Y-111 in FTDNA.
But even now we can do something.

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #25 : 26 Май 2018, 23:48:28 »
Цитировать
Do you know your own Great(5)-granfather name?
Yes, I know. Also 5, 6, 7 and more...
Цитировать
One more time. Just listen and try to understand.
:-X

Good.

And you know all descendants for 7 generations?

OK. Do you know at least 1 (one) the 6th Cousin by your and him paternal line?

Suppose. Could you explain how useful could be testing him for similar case?

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #26 : 26 Май 2018, 23:51:54 »
Let's see again:


Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #27 : 26 Май 2018, 23:55:09 »
What we see?

There is a common ancestor for Chinese, Polish and Ukrainian tested persons about 1700 yrs ago.

More precisely, between 1100 and 2400 ybp.

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #28 : 27 Май 2018, 00:02:21 »
The question is when. When they have this connection?

Alexander the Great times?
Or, Roman Empire epoque?
Maybe Silk Road Mediaval years?
The first Slavic invasion to China in 16-17th cc.?
Or modern day (18-19th cc.) Russian Empire expansion?

Doesn't matter.

The paternal relatives testing doesn't help us much.

It's much, much easier to see RIGHT NOW how long is TMRCA for the nearest STR match.

Оффлайн Mich Glitch

  • Genus regis
  • Сообщений: 30774
  • Страна: ca
  • Рейтинг +2261/-38
  • Y-ДНК: J2b1
  • мтДНК: H6a1a5
Re: Hi guys, R1a-Z280-YP951-YP4532* from China
« Ответ #29 : 27 Май 2018, 00:14:34 »
OK.

We have different solutions:

1. To test for unknown reasons your relatives.

2. Test yourself in FTDNA (Y-111).


*** BTW, still hope to receive some answers for your STR values from our forum members.

 

© 2007 Молекулярная Генеалогия (МолГен)

Внимание! Все сообщения отражают только мнения их авторов.
Все права на материалы принадлежат их авторам (владельцам) и сетевым изданиям, с которых они взяты.


Rambler's Top100